Instant On - Wired

Hello, 

Does anyone have any experience using Aruba Instant on with PF Sense and was it a positive experience?  

By positive experience I mean did VLANS work well and were you able to assign different VLANS to different SSIDs per AP?

Any other pointers for this setup would be appreciated. 

Thank you.

------------------------------
Jerome Toomey
------------------------------

Yes, I use this switch with both pfSense and opnSense and a pihole. It works great. 6 vlans, management, guest, home, semi-trusted, untrusted, servers. i manage the layer 3 routing at the firewall, not at the switch, because I don't need line speed between VLANs and the Senses make it very easy to administer. Just allocate your ports and put everything on a trunk (cisco talk) to the firewall. Don't "team" two ports to your pfSense--LAG should work, but it wasn't reliable on pfSense for some reason. If you need more bandwidth use a 10G connection.
Original Message:
Sent: 04-09-2021 09:42 AM
From: Jerome Toomey
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Hello, 

Does anyone have any experience using Aruba Instant on with PF Sense and was it a positive experience?  

By positive experience I mean did VLANS work well and were you able to assign different VLANS to different SSIDs per AP?

Any other pointers for this setup would be appreciated. 

Thank you.

------------------------------
Jerome Toomey
------------------------------

Thank you very much for your reply that is most helpful. I know this may be the wrong discussion section but are you using that for wireless as well and is that working? 

Thank you.

------------------------------
Jerome Toomey
------------------------------

Original Message:
Sent: 04-09-2021 05:37 PM
From: John Smith
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Yes, I use this switch with both pfSense and opnSense and a pihole. It works great. 6 vlans, management, guest, home, semi-trusted, untrusted, servers. i manage the layer 3 routing at the firewall, not at the switch, because I don't need line speed between VLANs and the Senses make it very easy to administer. Just allocate your ports and put everything on a trunk (cisco talk) to the firewall. Don't "team" two ports to your pfSense--LAG should work, but it wasn't reliable on pfSense for some reason. If you need more bandwidth use a 10G connection.
Original Message:
Sent: 04-09-2021 09:42 AM
From: Jerome Toomey
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Hello, 

Does anyone have any experience using Aruba Instant on with PF Sense and was it a positive experience?  

By positive experience I mean did VLANS work well and were you able to assign different VLANS to different SSIDs per AP?

Any other pointers for this setup would be appreciated. 

Thank you.

------------------------------
Jerome Toomey
------------------------------

I have a combination of Ubiquiti (phasing this out rapidly) and Cisco's CBW 240 AC line, (cheap and functional, works much better with iPhones than my old UBNT gear). I haven't tried the Aruba gear but it should be terrific.

I don't use a cloud controller and won't operate equipment that has to phone home to run. That is a non-negligible security and longevity risk in my humble opinion. The Ubnt hack in January shows why they should never be mandatory. Fortunately these InstantON switches don't require that at all.

By the way, if anyone at Aruba is reading this, please change your login page. Permit it to recall the user login name and most important, change the "sign up" and "sign on" buttons. Those are two completely different functions that should have completely different looks and placement. I've hit sign up a couple of times, then had to go back and enter my user name again--it's just an irritating paper cut.
Original Message:
Sent: 04-10-2021 06:32 AM
From: Jerome Toomey
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Thank you very much for your reply that is most helpful. I know this may be the wrong discussion section but are you using that for wireless as well and is that working? 

Thank you.

------------------------------
Jerome Toomey

Original Message:
Sent: 04-09-2021 05:37 PM
From: John Smith
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Yes, I use this switch with both pfSense and opnSense and a pihole. It works great. 6 vlans, management, guest, home, semi-trusted, untrusted, servers. i manage the layer 3 routing at the firewall, not at the switch, because I don't need line speed between VLANs and the Senses make it very easy to administer. Just allocate your ports and put everything on a trunk (cisco talk) to the firewall. Don't "team" two ports to your pfSense--LAG should work, but it wasn't reliable on pfSense for some reason. If you need more bandwidth use a 10G connection.
Original Message:
Sent: 04-09-2021 09:42 AM
From: Jerome Toomey
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Hello, 

Does anyone have any experience using Aruba Instant on with PF Sense and was it a positive experience?  

By positive experience I mean did VLANS work well and were you able to assign different VLANS to different SSIDs per AP?

Any other pointers for this setup would be appreciated. 

Thank you.

------------------------------
Jerome Toomey
------------------------------

I'm using OPNSense with a 1930 and 2 Aruba AP22s. I dropped Ubiquiti for the Arubas. Settings been great. Like JSmith I do routing at the OPNSense router. One because I'm running 10gb on it, and second because I get better visibility into the traffic between vlans.
Original Message:
Sent: 04-10-2021 06:32 AM
From: Jerome Toomey
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Thank you very much for your reply that is most helpful. I know this may be the wrong discussion section but are you using that for wireless as well and is that working? 

Thank you.

------------------------------
Jerome Toomey

Original Message:
Sent: 04-09-2021 05:37 PM
From: John Smith
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Yes, I use this switch with both pfSense and opnSense and a pihole. It works great. 6 vlans, management, guest, home, semi-trusted, untrusted, servers. i manage the layer 3 routing at the firewall, not at the switch, because I don't need line speed between VLANs and the Senses make it very easy to administer. Just allocate your ports and put everything on a trunk (cisco talk) to the firewall. Don't "team" two ports to your pfSense--LAG should work, but it wasn't reliable on pfSense for some reason. If you need more bandwidth use a 10G connection.
Original Message:
Sent: 04-09-2021 09:42 AM
From: Jerome Toomey
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Hello, 

Does anyone have any experience using Aruba Instant on with PF Sense and was it a positive experience?  

By positive experience I mean did VLANS work well and were you able to assign different VLANS to different SSIDs per AP?

Any other pointers for this setup would be appreciated. 

Thank you.

------------------------------
Jerome Toomey
------------------------------

I could use some help, I have an OpnSense firewall that I'm trying to replace a Cisco ASA with.    The ASA config is: interface Ethernet0/1
 description UPLINK (TRUNK) TO MGMT AND GUEST
 switchport trunk allowed vlan 60,302-303
 switchport mode trunk
 speed 100
 duplex full

I've added the vlans to the LAN interface of the OpnSense, it works when I plug my laptop in, I get DHCP and internet.  But when I use the cable from the ASA that is Trunk to the Aruba switch, I get nothing.

------------------------------
Nick Doud
------------------------------

Original Message:
Sent: 04-09-2021 05:37 PM
From: jsmith2020
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Yes, I use this switch with both pfSense and opnSense and a pihole. It works great. 6 vlans, management, guest, home, semi-trusted, untrusted, servers. i manage the layer 3 routing at the firewall, not at the switch, because I don't need line speed between VLANs and the Senses make it very easy to administer. Just allocate your ports and put everything on a trunk (cisco talk) to the firewall. Don't "team" two ports to your pfSense--LAG should work, but it wasn't reliable on pfSense for some reason. If you need more bandwidth use a 10G connection.
Original Message:
Sent: 04-09-2021 09:42 AM
From: Jerome Toomey
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Hello, 

Does anyone have any experience using Aruba Instant on with PF Sense and was it a positive experience?  

By positive experience I mean did VLANS work well and were you able to assign different VLANS to different SSIDs per AP?

Any other pointers for this setup would be appreciated. 

Thank you.

------------------------------
Jerome Toomey
------------------------------

Hi Nick,

Are you using cloud or local management on the Aruba switch?

If you are using local web gui:

On the port of the Aruba switch, you are connecting to, which vlans are defined?

Also, which vlan being used as "management" vlan on Aruba? 

------------------------------
Travis Thorne
------------------------------

Original Message:
Sent: 07-12-2024 04:18 PM
From: ndoud@insidefb.com
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

I could use some help, I have an OpnSense firewall that I'm trying to replace a Cisco ASA with.    The ASA config is: interface Ethernet0/1
 description UPLINK (TRUNK) TO MGMT AND GUEST
 switchport trunk allowed vlan 60,302-303
 switchport mode trunk
 speed 100
 duplex full

I've added the vlans to the LAN interface of the OpnSense, it works when I plug my laptop in, I get DHCP and internet.  But when I use the cable from the ASA that is Trunk to the Aruba switch, I get nothing.

------------------------------
Nick Doud

Original Message:
Sent: 04-09-2021 05:37 PM
From: jsmith2020
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Yes, I use this switch with both pfSense and opnSense and a pihole. It works great. 6 vlans, management, guest, home, semi-trusted, untrusted, servers. i manage the layer 3 routing at the firewall, not at the switch, because I don't need line speed between VLANs and the Senses make it very easy to administer. Just allocate your ports and put everything on a trunk (cisco talk) to the firewall. Don't "team" two ports to your pfSense--LAG should work, but it wasn't reliable on pfSense for some reason. If you need more bandwidth use a 10G connection.
Original Message:
Sent: 04-09-2021 09:42 AM
From: Jerome Toomey
Subject: PF Sense and Aruba Instant On

Hello, 

Does anyone have any experience using Aruba Instant on with PF Sense and was it a positive experience?  

By positive experience I mean did VLANS work well and were you able to assign different VLANS to different SSIDs per AP?

Any other pointers for this setup would be appreciated. 

Thank you.

------------------------------
Jerome Toomey
------------------------------